The following is a letter I’ve written my US Senators and Representative regarding the FBI’s attempt to force Apple to provide a backdoor into their iOS encryption framework.
I am strongly against the FBI’s attempt to force Apple to provide a backdoor into their iOS encryption framework.
I am not an iPhone user, but as a 15-year veteran of the tech industry, I am intimately familiar with the importance of encryption in today’s technology ecosystem. If the FBI were to force Apple into providing a backdoor into their encryption framework, there is little to ensure that this capability is limited to this one case and absolutely nothing to prevent others from using it once created. To expect that the custom iOS provided to the FBI would never get into the hands of hackers and enemy states is naive and dangerous. Nor is there anything to prevent the FBI or other government security agencies from using this against US citizens in the future.
Forcing Apple to provide a backdoor sets a terrible precedent. It will negatively impact the US technology sector, and thereby the US economy, as individuals and businesses (both within the US and outside of it) stop purchasing US-made equipment knowing that the US government has, or can have, a route into their data.
Privacy and security are inherently at odds with one another and I acknowledge that it is hard to find a balance between the two. But the US government should be directing tech companies to do a better job of protecting citizen’s privacy, not providing backdoors to allow the US government and others to violate that privacy.
Please put pressure on the FBI to withdraw their request from Apple and make it clear that American citizens need strong encryption to protect our privacy and the US economy.
Those who would give up essential Liberty, to purchase a little temporary Safety, deserve neither Liberty nor Safety.
— Benjamin Franklin